Library Header Image Library Header Image

Should You Consolidate on a Unified CNAPP?


Posted on by Tatyana Sanchez

Key Takeaways:
  • Consolidation trades depth for context. A unified CNAPP may give up about 10% of niche capability in exchange for far better cross-domain risk correlation.
  • Migration is a cultural shift, not just a technical cutover. Run tools in parallel so engineering workflows and trust aren’t disrupted.
  • Test it against your top three cloud risks. If your current stack takes hours or days to connect the dots on them, consolidation likely makes sense.

Excessive permissions are behind many identity-based breaches in the cloud, and an astounding 95% of organizations reported they have experienced a cloud security breach.

Meanwhile, cloud security teams aren't short on alerts. Posture management, container security and identity governance tools each flag issues in their own console, so connecting an overly permissive IAM role to the vulnerability it exposes can take hours of digging.

That's why so many organizations are weighing a move to a unified cloud native application protection platform, or CNAPP. The pitch is compelling: less alert fatigue, better risk correlation and fewer consoles to juggle. But consolidation isn't a free win, and it isn't right for everyone.

So, Kacy Zurkus and I sat down with Steve Turner, Head of Security Platforms at Guardian, to understand where unified platforms deliver, where they fall short, and how security leaders can tell whether the move makes sense for their organization.

What's really driving the push toward consolidation?

Turner: It really boils down to context and sprawl. When you have separate, siloed tools for posture management, container security and identity governance, security teams are just drowning in disconnected alerts.

Does that promise hold up once a CNAPP is actually deployed?

Turner: In reality, it takes work. You don't just buy a CNAPP, plug it in and magically get perfection. If the tool can't speak the language of your organization, the promise completely falls flat.

How does a unified CNAPP compare with a best-of-breed stack or your cloud provider's native tooling?

Turner: It's this classic jack-of-all-trades versus master-of-none dilemma. Best-of-breed tools give us the deepest visibility into very niche areas, while native cloud provider tooling is virtually frictionless to turn on, but it struggles the second you introduce a multi-cloud strategy.

So what's the tradeoff?

Turner: You might sacrifice about 10% of that ultra-deep, granular capability you get from a best-of-breed niche tool. In return, the promise is 90% better context through cross-domain correlation. What migration risks should teams plan for?

What migration risks should teams plan for?

Turner: Disruption to workflows is the biggest one by far. If you suddenly rip out the tools your engineering teams rely on without warning, you're going to break their trust and quickly become ‘the department of no.’

How can teams reduce those risks?

Turner: I'm a big fan of having the solutions running in parallel during the transition. The biggest misunderstanding I've seen is treating these migrations as just a technical cutover, when in reality it's a large cultural shift.

When is consolidation the wrong call?

Turner: If you have a very hyper-specialized environment, sticking to native or specialized tools makes sense. You don't force a square peg into a round hole just for the sake of saying you have a single dashboard.

What's one concrete step leaders can take to decide?

Turner: Map out your top three most critical cloud risks right now. If your current disconnected security stack takes your team hours or days to piece together an alert for those risks, you've immediately got your answer.

That's only the first step. Turner also shares how to test whether a CNAPP is worth the investment before you commit your whole organization to it.

To hear the rest of Turner's advice, listen to the full conversation on the RSAC Cyber at the Top podcast episode, Addressing the Tradeoffs of Adopting a Unified CNAPP

Contributors
Tatyana Sanchez

Senior Coordinator, Content & Programming, RSAC

Blogs posted to the RSAConference.com website are intended for educational purposes only and do not replace independent professional judgment. Statements of fact and opinions expressed are those of the blog author individually and, unless expressly stated to the contrary, are not the opinion or position of RSAC™ Conference, or any other co-sponsors. RSAC Conference does not endorse or approve, and assumes no responsibility for, the content, accuracy or completeness of the information presented in this blog.


Share With Your Community

Related Blogs